The 75mm Renaissance. Why the Best Lens on the Market is a $2,500 Used Leica!
Lately, the 75mm is having a massive renaissance. It seems like every boutique lens manufacturer and third party brand is suddenly flooding the market with new 75mm options. We are seeing everything from ultra fast glass attempting to push the limits of depth of field to highly compact, affordable options trying to claim a permanent spot in your camera bag.
But before you buy a Noctilux, a Voigtlander, or one of the newer Chinese made lenses, it is vital that we don't forget the benchmark. We need to look past the marketing noise and talk about the undisputed baseline by which all others must be measured, my favorite and one and only Leica 75mm f2 APO Summicron M ASPH.
Even with a sea of new, trendy choices, this legendary piece of German engineering remains the definitive king of the focal length and the wisest investment you can make. Considering these sell new for nearly $6,000.00 and you can find used mint ones online for $2500.00 makes this a no brainer.
However, you cannot talk about Leica 75mm lenses without addressing the elephant in the room, the nearly $16,000 75mm Noctilux M f1.25. The Noctilux is a staggering feat of optical over engineering. It is also, for the vast majority of working photographers, an exercise in pure fiscal insanity. Demanding well north of $15,000 brand new, it is a lens designed more for a climate controlled collectors' safes than actual shooting. I have seen on line reviewers compare this to less expensive options without much difference in the end result. But, you will no dobt be making a statement with that beast hanging around your neck.
On a rangefinder, shooting a 75mm focal length wide open at f1.25 presents a depth of field so razor thin that it borders on the unusable. Take a portrait, and you might get a beautifully rendered eyelash while the iris itself falls completely out of focus. It is massive, it is incredibly heavy, it completely blocks your viewfinder, and it turns a nimble rangefinder setup into a front heavy behemoth. Might as well shoot a DSLR with a fast 85. Simply put, in my opinion, the Noctilux is a status symbol while the Summicron is a tool.
The true genius of the 75 f2 APO shines brightest when you look at the secondary market. While a brand new copy commands a premium, you can regularly find a pristine, mint conditioned used version sitting right around the $2,500 to $3,000 mark. Go and look at
PopFlash.com or
Tim Lei on Instagram for some incredible deals. For the price of a generic modern mirrorless zoom, or just a bit more than the newest third party boutique offerings, you are stepping into absolute apochromatic perfection.
At this price point, the 75 cron ceases to be an unattainable luxury and turns into an absolute steal for what you get. It holds its resale worth beautifully, features a built in retractable lens hood that is an absolute joy to use, and offers a compact form factor that balances flawlessly on an M body without obscuring your framing lines.
What separates this lens from the newer, faster Voigtlander glass or the deluge of cheaper Chinese pretenders to the throne? It comes down to three letters. APO.
An apochromatic lens is corrected to bring three wavelengths of light (red, green, and blue) into the exact same focal plane. In lesser, uncorrected lenses, these colors focus at slightly different distances, resulting in lateral and longitudinal chromatic aberrations, those distracting green and magenta color fringing you see along high contrast edges.
The 75 Summicron eliminates this entirely. Wide open at f2, the lens delivers a level of micro contrast, and edge to edge sharpness that is staggering. It does not need to be stopped down to perform, its peak performance is delivered right from f2. Although I will say, that focusing can be difficult sometimes as even f2 has a razor thin DOF. Using an EVF like the Visoflex when critical focus is a must is not a bad idea.
Many of the newer 75mm lenses on the market try to sell themselves on character which I often say is just a marketing euphemism for uncorrected optical flaws, heavy vignetting, or swirling, distracting bokeh. (
Except for the new Re-issue Leica 50mm Summilux Classic which is true Character 100% ).
The 75 APO doesn't play those games. It doesn't fake its 3D rendering through messy distortion. Instead, it creates an incredibly realistic, lifelike pop because the transition from the sharp focal plane to the buttery, smooth fall off of the background is incredibly clean. The bokeh is gorgeous, polite, understated, and completely free of onion rings or harsh transitions. It isolates your subject not by destroying the background into mush, but by rendering the subject with such transparent clarity that they look three dimensional.
My only complaint about this lens is that I don't use it as often as I should and sometimes think about reselling it. But, after writing this blog post, those thoughts get completely eliminated and the len goes back into my bag. Which is not complete and ready for travel with the following:
One Leica M11 ( glossy black )
One Leica 50mm Summilux Non Asph re-issue classic
One Zeiss 35mm Distagon ( better than any other 35 for the M. Yes even Better than the FLE )
One Leica 75mm APO Summicron
One Visoflex 2. Rarely used but there just in case it's needed.
I still go back and fourth between taking the 35 Zeiss Distagon or the Voigtlander 28mm 1.5 Nokton.
Before we jump into the sample files, let’s look at the options flooding the market right now. If you are shopping around, these are the alternative routes you can take, though as you will see, none of them offer the total package of the used Leica APO.
TTArtisan / 7Artisans 75mm f/1.25 or f/2. If you are on a strict budget and just want a cheap piece of glass to experiment with the focal length, fine. They have their place for affordability. But when we are talking about serious, professional optical performance, they shouldn't even be part of the same discussion. Not to mention we don't fully know how they hold up over the years.
The Voigtlander 75mm f/1.5 Nokton, f/1.9 Ultron or even the new highly regarded 75 f2.8 apo Skopar. Voigtlander makes phenomenal, well built gear, and these are very respectable choices if you buy new. The f1.5 gives you more speed, but it leans into that stylized character rather than what I call the absolute, unvarnished truth. They are great lenses, but they aren't an APO Summicron. Although the new Skopar as reviewed by
Fred Miranda is trying and is a strong competitor. I love my Voigtlanders especially my 28's and 50's but I adore my 75 Summicron.
Leica 75mm f/1.4 Summilux, designed by Mandler. I had one of these years ago and should have kept it just as an investment. This classic is a portrait legend famed for its glowing, creamy wide open look. It has character in spades, but it's a completely different tool than the APO. It's soft wide open, prone to fringing in harsh light, heavy, and commands a massive collector's premium used.
The insanely priced Leica 75mm f/1.25 Noctilux. As I mentioned above, it's a $16,000 status symbol. It's an optical masterpiece, but it's a front heavy elephant that ruins the rangefinder experience and belongs in a safe, not on the street. It would make cool looking bliong around someones neck. But you need a neck like Fred Flinstone for that.
With that landscape in mind, let’s look at how the 75mm APO actually performs where it matters most. Out in the real world.
Finally I agree with what you wrote
You can see my photos on FB
Take care Dan Bar